Of all the arguments being used in the half-staff flag debate, this is the one that I understand the least (emphasis mine):
My biggest concern with lowering the flag for soldiers killed in Afstan is that it creates a perception of inequality among soldiers killed in this mission and soldiers killed in other missions. Aside from special cases, it is unfair to the memories of our fallen heroes and their families to distinguish the deaths in this way.
Unfair? Really? This is all about conistency and fairness? This is such a bogus argument that I don’t know where to start.
We lower the flags for a Member of Parliament or an appointed (!) Senator, but not for someone who volunteers to put his or her life on the line and then pays the price, because we didn’t do it in the past every time?
How far back does one measure this “consistency” to form a useful measure? Let’s apply the same argument to healthcare – the federal government used to contribute 25% of the healthcare costs to the provinces – is Harper going to pony up that amount of cash now for historical consistency? Or, since for much of the history of Canada we didn’t actually have socialized health care, so maybe we should just scrap the whole damned thing? (Okay, this one might be on the table.)
There is a story from these here parts that Edward Cornwallis used to pay 50 pounds for the scalps of the local native populations. Isn’t it historically inconsistent to no longer continue this “tradition” with the Mi’kmaq?
Of course, the same person that posted this messy rationalization revealed their partisan stripes in this little unjustified snipe:
Today, in Sinai, Egypt, Canadian soldiers (multinational soldiers, infact) came underattack by two suicide bombers. *IF* this attack had killed a Canadian soldier and IF* the Liberals had won the past election, I guarantee you they would not have lowered the flag to half mast to honour the death.
*IF* this argument wasn’t specious and *IF* its author not blinded by partisan politics I guarantee that I would have saved fifteen minutes by not having to write this.
Can we at least talk sensibly about this issue? Please?