maritimes, politics

Peter and Elizabeth up a tree…

The announcement yesterday that Green Party leader Elizabeth May will run in Peter Mackay’s riding of Central Nova in the next federal election is interesting for a number of reasons. A locally fairly popular and high profile cabinet minister, it is certainly an interesting choice for May, who currently lives in Ontario. Unfortunately, I think her announcement serves to guarantee that he keeps his seat next time around, and I think he’s mighty glad to have her on board, as it were. Maybe I’m under-estimating the importance of the environment as a campaign issue, but I just don’t think it will cause enough votes to walk to a fringe candidate in that riding.

For those not familiar with Nova Scotia politics, voters are divided pretty much along rural (Conservative) and urban (NDP / Liberal) lines. Also, there is a tendancy towards voting for established political dynasties, provided the progeny prove to at least have opposable thumbs. Three current dynasties come to mind – Savage, Regan, and yes, Mackay. In addition, while it is a little unfair to say that all Bluenosers tend to vote as their parents did, it would not be far from the truth to say that rural ridings are less likely to warm quickly to new parties. Whether Peter Mackay is an effective minister or not is an open debate (hell, if any of them are effective is), but at the very least, he has not embarassed his home town, so he would seem to have a starting advantage over any opponent.

So why choose Central Nova?

First, the riding actually includes a couple of larger towns (Maritime-wise, that is) and also includes St. Francis Xavier University, so there is a fair proportion of young “hip” voters that might give the Greens a boost. At the very least, they would provide a population of potential volunteers should a vote be called during the school year. For a party that is likely going to run on a shoe-string budget, most of which will likely be spent in one riding, this has to be a consideration.

Also, in the last election, Alexis MacDonald, the NDP candidate, performed quite well, finishing second with 33% of the vote. There is a constituency in the riding that could well be swayed into the Green camp for sure.

However I feel it overly hopeful, if not downright silly to think that all or most of the NDP support, and a goodly chunk of the Liberals, would walk over to the Greens. Especially to a “come from away” candidate that does not live in the riding and has no real connection to the place. (Yes, I know Brian Mulroney won there, but he was Conservative, and the leader of a party that was a legitimate threat to become government. The Greens are neither.) Elizabeth May’s presence in this race will serve more to divide the non-Conservative vote and I fully expect that, without a massive gaffe from Mackay (never too far off to be sure), he will hold the riding with potentially a larger margin overall. Unless of course the Liberals plan to throw the riding altogether.

So really, why Central Nova?

Aye, that’s the question. May undoubtedly wants to make a good run for a seat, but surely there are safer ridings to get involved with. My feeling is that she wants to look tough, fight a good fight, but not win. It’s a passive-aggressive kind of move that will both raise her profile and not tie her to a behind-a-pillar seat in the House of Commons where she will rarely, if ever, be heard from or seen.

Also, it is a thumb in the eyes of the NDP, who could actually win that seat were the circumstances of the election call favourable.

Alas, it is not to be.


12 thoughts on “Peter and Elizabeth up a tree…

  1. The fact that Mackay is potentially vulnerable because of screw-ups like that is what makes this the most galling. Alexis MacDonald, if she were to run again, definitely has a chance to take this riding, but I think that her chances are much diminished now, and I thing May hasn’t really got a prayer.


  2. And so we have the profacy of chantel Herbert (Toronto Star) where the supposed progressives dual and essentially let the con win. perhaps Mae thinks that some disfranished cons move her way, except that Mckay comes from the red tory type and not the neocon type. For all that blather of May saying she wants to work with other parties, her actions speak louder than words. As I read somewhere else and found quite funny, was a poster stating that by Mae choicing to run in a riding that she has little chance of winning shows her not to be a serious leader.


  3. what’s interesting is that May does have ties to Cape Breton – her family home is in Margaree. Maybe someone can tell me – who’s representing the Cape Breton ridings right now, and why wouldn’t she run there?


  4. Dan, Margaree is in Cape Breton-Canso, which was handily won by the Liberals last time by 25%. Perhaps there is something to the Sun’s suggestion that the Liberals want to throw Central Nova? It makes sense – back someone in a riding that you know you can’t win rather than in one that you can win easily.


  5. A high-profile opponent like MacKay is an “opponent with benefits”. She will get heaps of press and – as you say – she will look tough by having a go at MacKay. And who knows what might happen, even in Pictou County…

    Now, let’s talk about Jane Purves going against Alexa M. Another high profile seat she probably won’t win, but wouldn’t it set her up nicely to take a run at the Tory leadership when the Tories finally wake up and dump old Roddo the Dodo.


  6. GT – you’re right, Purves vs. MacDonough is pretty much a guaranteed loss for Jane, and I think she knows it. However, she only has to do better than previous Conservative contenders in the riding to get a leg up on her provincial counterparts in a run for the leadership. Excellent observation.

    I wonder how long young Rodney has left?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s